• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Conestoga Style Pizza

At Conestoga Style Pizza, we celebrate 47 years of crafting delicious pizzas in Bryn Mawr, PA. Our story is one of dedication, quality, and community. We take pride in our perfectly baked crusts and rich flavors, ranging from classic pepperoni to unique Buffalo chicken. With many vegetarian options and delectable salads, there's something for everyone. Our welcoming atmosphere is perfect for families, featuring outdoor seating and a kid-friendly menu. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or enjoying delivery, each pie is made with care, ready to delight your taste buds. Join us for an unforgettable pizza experience!

Conestoga Style Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Al C.
Al C.

They really did pay attention to the preparation of my small pizza. It came out perfectly baked the crust was perfect. Apparently they have been in business for 47 years, that is a solid indicator of quality and loyalty.

Sinead G.
Sinead G.

Ever since I moved from NYC been looking for a pizza place. Workers were kind and pizza was delicious. Best I've found since moving here last May.

Blake F.
Blake F.

I had a delivery order from Conestoga Style Pizza. We ordered a couple of pies including plain, pepperoni and Buffalo chicken. I had two slices of the plain pizza, which was very solid. I liked how the base of the pizza and the crust had a buttery flavor. There was a good ratio of cheese to sauce. There was nothing spectacular about either, but it went well with the crust. The delivery driver was a nice guy, who made sure everything about the order was good and he gave us utensils and napkins. Conestoga Style Pizza is a solid pizzeria that and I may order from there again. Altogether, Conestoga Style Pizza is a good pizzeria serving tasty pies and I would recommend them.

Richie H.
Richie H.

Solid pizza. Crispy crust and perfectly cooked. Would grab a pie again! Prices are also pretty reasonable too

B B.
B B.

Fantastic pie! Been looking for a solid basic pizza in the area that wasn't over priced and cooked to order. The request of lightly cooked was spot on and delivery was fast enough the pizza was still hot. They have just become my go to in the area!

James P.
James P.

Very good, very old school pizza shop cheese steak. You walk in and you know these guys have been making cheesesteaks together for a long time. I am 99% sure it was a Conshohocken Bakery roll. I like my Conshohocken Bakery rolls. They melted the cheese onto the role in the pizza oven, yummy. I love that. They season the meat nicely so it had a nice flavor. It was $8.50, you know I didn't hate that. It was on the small side. Very good overall experience and the winner of my mini Bryn Mawr looking across Conestoga Road at each other cheesesteak Showdown.

Location

Welcome to Conestoga Style Pizza, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania. This pizzeria has been a beloved staple in the community for an impressive 47 years, earning a reputation for delivering not just pizza, but warm hospitality and quality service. Whether you're looking for a place to enjoy a meal with family or a spot to grab a quick bite, Conestoga Style Pizza caters to all.

Located at 905 Conestoga Rd, this establishment offers a delightful array of options that go beyond traditional pizza, including a range of sandwiches, strombolis, and appetizing sides. The menu caters to various dietary needs, featuring many vegetarian options that please even the most discerning palates. With the convenience of both delivery and takeout, you can enjoy their scrumptious offerings anywhere you're comfortable. And for those sunny days, outdoor seating awaits, allowing you to savor your meal al fresco.

  • Signature Dishes: Famous for their perfectly baked pizzas, the buttery crust and balanced cheese-to-sauce ratio have left many customers singing their praises. Reviewers like Al C. remark on the precise preparation and cooking, reinforcing the pizzeria's commitment to quality.
  • Sandwich Selections: From classic ham and cheese to the indulgent grilled chicken, there's a sandwich for everyone, making it a great choice for lunch or a light dinner.
  • Stromboli Variety: The selection of strombolis, including the Conestoga Special and Vegetarian options, gives you a unique twist on your favorite flavors.
  • Family-Friendly Atmosphere: With an ambiance that suits families well, it's no wonder that customers rave about Conestoga as a great spot to dine out with kids.

Not only is the food enjoyable, but the staff at Conestoga Style Pizza enhances the experience. Many customers have expressed their appreciation for the friendly service they received during their visits, making each dining experience feel personal and welcoming.

For those who enjoy a good pie, Conestoga Style Pizza stands out as a reliable choice. Its long-standing presence in the local scene is a testament to its dedication and passion for delicious food. So whether you're indulging in a classic cheese pizza, relishing the crunchy goodness of their Buffalo chicken slices, or simply exploring their wide array of dishes, you are in for a treat. Experience the flavors of Conestoga Style Pizza today, and join the ranks of satisfied customers who have made this pizzeria their go-to for tasty, quality pizza.